Delivery was a bit early, which was great. Had wings and they were delicious. Meaty, nicely cooked and the sauce very tasty. Greek salad was fine (wished they had a Greek dressing). Pizza was cooked well, had a good amount of toppings and tasted very good. Had the Tomato, Onion, Mozzarella with added Sausage and Mushrooms. Will definitely order again.
The delivery driver (not a Sammy's employee) just destroyed the original pizza. It arrived in a wad in the corner of the box and the cardboard was soaked through. It was comically bad. But I called Sammy's and they were very kind and sent another one right away. It was absolutely delicious. Sammy's is Ithaca's best pizza.
Great food. I was pleasantly surprised to see the chicken tenders were hand breaded with a very tasty panko topping. Fries were done just right. Driver was actually a little earlier than GrubHub said he would be. Food was piping hot when I opened the box.
Mac and cheese is decent size/price. If there's one quibble I have its that the only way, thru grubhub at least, to order loaded fries is to get them as additional side when you order a burrito. Otherwise they don't show up as an option.
Sammy's Pizzeria is easily my favorite restaurant to order from. Just as with any business, they may mess up every now and then, but unlike others, they will always make it right and will go above and beyond for their customers.
Reviews from Seamless.com
The food was perfect for a couple whove had the flu all week.
American, Calzones, Dinner, Late Night, Lunch Specials, Pizza, Sandwiches
Delivery: 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Takeout: 11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Sammy's Pizzeria knows how to keep hungry diners happy. Sammy's makes all of its food with fresh ingredients, and its authentic flavors are sure to keep you coming back for more. Order today to experience for yourself!
Online ordering for delivery or takeout!
Whether you're craving a quick bite or looking to treat yourself to a delicious meal, you can now order your Sammy's Pizzeria favorites for takeout or delivery.